Brendan O’Neill’s home run against Monbiot

MoonbeamLove Brendan O’Neill. This article is nothing short of a straight home run against Moonbeam George Monbiot, a columnist in the Guardian with whom we’ve taken much issue in the past on this very blog (john-wright.net search term ‘Monbiot‘). By analyzing Monbiot’s past, we understand his present, and it’s quite an amusing picture. Excerpts:

“Not many moons ago, Monbiot was looked upon by many people as a green-ink eccentric, who was probably given a newspaper column on the same basis that friends of the Marquis de Sade smuggled scraps of paper and pots of ink into his cell in the Charenton insane asylum: because if he’s kept busy writing, he won’t go utterly off his nut.”

“Like a latter-day Christian recluse, he wrote of his horror at hearing the sound of human laughter. ‘The world is dying, and people are killing themselves with laughter’, he wailed (3). So disturbed was he by the ‘gales of laughter’ sweeping Britain that he was moved to quote Kierkegaard: ‘This is the way I think the world will end – with general giggling by all the witty heads, who think it is a joke.’”

“The metamorphosis of Monbiot is telling. It shows, in microcosm (after all, we’re only talking about the Guardian comment pages here), how the politics and science of environmentalism have added a new, legitimising coating to elite fears and prejudices. The most striking thing about the rise and rise (and rise) of the environmentalist ethos is how it has acted as a life support machine for the political and cultural elite’s contempt for the lifestyles of the lower orders, and how it has added a new scientific/end of the world twist to the authorities’ attempts to manage, control and change our behaviour and expectations.”

See the rest of this great piece here.

2 Responses to “Brendan O’Neill’s home run against Monbiot”


  1. 1 Liam

    Interesting piece.

    I’m not Brendan O’Neill’s biggest fan, I sometimes think he’s not as clever as he believes. I also believe the issue of possible man-made global warming is a serious one and try to recycle etc.

    However, O’Neill has administered a clinical, thorough and deserved kicking to Monbiot here. I remember the article Georgieboy wrote about commuters at Liverpool Street station and thinking at the time that he was as mad as a bag of eels. His hatred of people having the nerve to ENJOY life is really quite something.

    John I’ve had a lot of trouble posting links. Is this a problem for the site? I have some quite good ones about eco-mania and the misanthropy it leads to.

  2. 2 John

    Hmmm….. there shouldn’t be a problem posting links at all….. but I think our spam filter may be working overtime. I’ll try and get it sorted. :)

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared.

RSS for Posts RSS for Comments