Europe interferes in Apple’s business again

When will the European Union learn that it has no right to interfere in private business decisions? The news today that Europe is launching an antitrust probe against Apple, Universal, Sony BMG, Warner and EMI should come as no surprise to those, like myself, who have been closely watching the increasing tenacity with which [...]

When will the European Union learn that it has no right to interfere in private business decisions? The news today that Europe is launching an antitrust probe against Apple, Universal, Sony BMG, Warner and EMI should come as no surprise to those, like myself, who have been closely watching the increasing tenacity with which Europe is stomping over the freedoms of those who are unfortunate enough to live or do business within its jurisdiction.

Apple is – even at this stage – probably better off perservering with these pretentious pricks for business reasons than to do as I would love to see them do: pull out of Europe completely and let them suffer the consequences. Wouldn’t it be wonderful to see every large American corporation shut their operations in Europe under an ultimatum? ‘We’ll bring your streets to a standstill unless you get the fuck out of our way and let us do business unimpeded by your bureaucratic bullshit.’ We can’t even begin to imagine the beauty of the devastation it would cause. Lessons would be learned, and quickly.

If rights were of concern to the E.U. they would know that to exercise power of any kind over someone’s intellectual property rights is to steal from those people the ownership of their own labour. But Europe, as usual, doesn’t see it that way, which may go a long way toward explaining why the economy in the United States is sizzling while Europe’s ticks along lethargically.

I don’t know who is going to do it, but someone must put these arrogant bastards in their place.

John Wright

johnwright@softhome.net

7 Comments

  1. Greg, Sacramento on April 4, 2007 | Permalink

    What are you objecting to? Apple is a huge corporation that gets its way wherever it goes. Are you telling me that the EU curbing some of this anti-competitive streak is wrong? Come on John.

  2. John Wright on April 4, 2007 | Permalink

    Greg- Your comment is ludicrous. Do large corporations have less rights than smaller ones? Or is all business ultimately auditable by the state, no matter the reason?

    Apple has simply been successful in its business model; thus the reason for the EU probe. It is possible to be too successful in Europe. Success is not something the EU values in business. Let me ask you a question, Greg. If you created something spectacular from the ground up, would you or would you not be incensed at the suggestion that it was simply too good to be permitted by your government?

  3. Greg, Sacramento on April 4, 2007 | Permalink

    Of course the state should be able to audit businesses, would you have allowed Enron to continue unabated? Corporations should not be allowed to run crazy and do whatever they want, they need to be socially responsible. In this case Apple and the music companies have a complete monopoly allowing nobody else to even attempt to enter the market. I thought you were pro-consumer?

  4. John Wright on April 4, 2007 | Permalink

    Greg- Enron was a blatant case of accounting fraud. Fraud is, rightly, a crime. In the case above, Apple and the music companies have created innovative ways to digitise and sell music via the internet for the first time, building many of the protocols, formats and systems necessary for such an undertaking from scratch and shouldering painstaking negotiations to make it happen. Their only crime was that their enterprise was a commercial success… it’s Europe that’s made success a crime.

    And your comment about a monopoly is incredibly dumb Greg, though it appears there are plenty of Europeans willing to agree with you. The only thing I’ll say in response is that any company that works as hard as Apple did with respect to digital music distribution will have a shot at being as successful as them. And there are several that have already piggybacked off the original Apple deal to create their own with similar pricing and a similar function; there isn’t any reason why they can’t compete with Apple. To call iTunes a monopoly is a fucking lie, Greg. A monopoly is a situation in which there is only one provider of a product or service: in this case there’s one that 80 percent of consumers are using, but plenty of other options. Again, Apple simply has the most successful product. That is NOT a monopoly; it’s a successful business.

    When people learn to stop criminalising, penalising and demonising success, and instead start to permit, emulate and admire it…. things will be better for all of us.

  5. Anonymous on April 5, 2007 | Permalink

    I think Greg is defending the use of the word monopoly to describe Apple’s position because as you say it is 80% of music downloads. THe EU investigation is to find out why all of these other companies have only 20% of the market.

  6. John Wright on April 5, 2007 | Permalink

    The reason Apple have 80 percent of the music download market is because they did 80 percent of the work in establishing agreements with the music companies that permitted legal downloads. People liked iTunes, people bought music from iTunes and, presto, iTunes gets to be the most popular service.

    Now. Either the European Union is stupid and doesn’t know this… (not likely) …or it deliberately has a problem with success in a belief that too much success warrants the interference and penalising measures of government. If you two think that’s the legitimate role of government, I can’t help you any further.

  7. S Quinney on April 6, 2007 | Permalink

    I can’t understand why anyone would defend trying to penalize our most successful groups of people while rewarding our least productive with welfare of all kinds. Does that make a lick of sense?

POST A COMMENT

Your email is never published nor shared.

CONNECT

John on Facebook

FOLLOW

John on Twitter

LISTEN

John at KLPZ